One of the most exciting developments
in modern neuroscience is the growing understanding of the glymphatic system—the
brain's own waste-clearance system.
This network circulates cerebrospinal
fluid (CSF) through the brain, removing metabolic waste products and helping
maintain a healthy neuronal environment. Remarkably, the glymphatic system is most
active during deep (slow-wave) sleep, suggesting that one of sleep's most
important functions is to clean the brain.
Interest in this system has exploded
over the past decade because impaired glymphatic function has now been
implicated in Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, traumatic brain injury,
stroke and several other neurological disorders.
Increasingly, researchers are also
asking whether glymphatic dysfunction contributes to autism spectrum disorder
(ASD).
A remarkably
recent discovery
One of the most surprising aspects of
this story is just how new it is.
The glymphatic system was only
discovered in 2012 by Professor Maiken Nedergaard and colleagues. Until then,
neuroscientists knew that the brain produced metabolic waste, but nobody really
understood how it was removed. Unlike the rest of the body, the brain appeared
to have no conventional lymphatic system.
The discovery of the glymphatic system
transformed our understanding of brain biology. Researchers showed that
cerebrospinal fluid flows alongside arteries into the brain, exchanges with the
fluid surrounding brain cells, and then carries away waste products before
leaving alongside veins.
Only three years later, in 2015,
another major breakthrough followed when researchers discovered meningeal
lymphatic vessels surrounding the brain. These vessels drain fluid from the
glymphatic system into the body's lymphatic system.
Together, these discoveries revealed
that the brain possesses its own sophisticated waste-disposal network.
Considering that this entire field is
little more than a decade old, it is remarkable how quickly it has expanded.
Today, impaired glymphatic function has been linked to Alzheimer's disease,
Parkinson's disease, multiple sclerosis, traumatic brain injury, stroke,
depression, schizophrenia and, increasingly, autism.
Autism and the
glymphatic system
Until recently, the idea that
glymphatic dysfunction might contribute to autism was based largely on indirect
observations.
Researchers had reported:
- enlarged extra-axial cerebrospinal fluid
in some infants who later develop autism,
- enlarged perivascular spaces,
- chronic neuroinflammation,
- and the very high prevalence of sleep
disorders in autism.
Now, neuroimaging studies are
beginning to provide more direct evidence.
A newly published MRI study examined 78 children with autism and 48 typically developing controls using the DTI-ALPS technique, a non-invasive MRI method that estimates glymphatic activity. The investigators found significantly reduced glymphatic function in the autism group. Even more interestingly, poorer glymphatic function correlated with more severe communication difficulties and poorer visual-motor integration. Statistical modelling suggested that impaired visual-motor integration partly explained the relationship between glymphatic dysfunction and communication deficits.
The authors concluded that impaired glymphatic clearance may contribute to the pathophysiology of autism and represents a promising area for future mechanistic and interventional research.
These studies do not prove that
impaired glymphatic clearance causes autism. However, they do suggest that it
may contribute to the biology of at least a subgroup of autistic individuals.
Why deep sleep
matters
Perhaps the most important aspect of
the glymphatic system is that it works best during deep slow-wave sleep.
During deep sleep:
- cerebrospinal fluid flows more
efficiently through the brain,
- the space between brain cells expands,
- metabolic waste products are removed,
- inflammatory molecules are cleared,
- and the brain performs what is
essentially its nightly housekeeping.
Sleep disturbances affect around 50–80%
of autistic children, often continuing into adulthood. If glymphatic clearance
depends on deep sleep, this raises the possibility that chronic sleep
disruption contributes to impaired waste clearance, neuroinflammation and
altered brain function, creating a vicious cycle.
This may be one reason why improving
sleep often has benefits that extend well beyond simply reducing daytime
fatigue.
Aquaporin-4: the
brain's plumbing protein
The glymphatic system depends on a
protein called aquaporin-4 (AQP4), which forms tiny water channels in the
end-feet of astrocytes—support cells that surround the brain's blood vessels.
These channels allow cerebrospinal
fluid to move efficiently between blood vessels and brain tissue, helping wash
away metabolic waste products. In animal experiments, deleting AQP4
dramatically reduces glymphatic clearance, highlighting its central role in the
brain's waste-disposal system.
Interestingly, several studies have
reported altered AQP4 expression or localisation in autism. Although it is
still unclear whether these changes are a cause or a consequence of autism,
they provide another possible explanation for why glymphatic function may be
impaired in at least some autistic individuals.
Exercise may also
support the brain's cleaning system
Exercise is another intervention that
may enhance glymphatic function.
Experimental studies suggest that
regular physical activity can:
- improve vascular health,
- improve sleep quality,
- enhance cerebrospinal fluid dynamics,
- reduce neuroinflammation,
- and potentially improve glymphatic
clearance.
Even if future studies show only
modest effects on glymphatic function, exercise already has well-established
benefits for cardiovascular health, cognition, mood and healthy ageing.
This brings us to one of the most intriguing studies published in the last 12 months.
Researchers investigated whether they
could artificially stimulate the glymphatic system by having volunteers breathe
alternating short periods of air containing 5% carbon dioxide, followed by
normal air.
Rather than continuously increasing
carbon dioxide, the intermittent exposure generated rhythmic expansion and
contraction of cerebral blood vessels.
Brain imaging demonstrated increased
cerebrospinal fluid movement, while blood tests suggested increased movement of
brain-derived proteins into the circulation, consistent with enhanced
glymphatic clearance.
Importantly, this was not an autism or
Alzheimer's treatment study. It was a proof-of-concept experiment involving
healthy older adults and people with Parkinson's disease.
Nevertheless, it demonstrated
something remarkable:
The human
glymphatic system appears to be modifiable.
Mimicking what
happens during deep sleep
Perhaps the most fascinating aspect of
the study is the proposed mechanism.
The intermittent carbon dioxide
exposure generated slow vascular oscillations remarkably similar to those
naturally seen during deep sleep, when glymphatic clearance reaches its
maximum.
In effect, the researchers may have
temporarily reproduced one of the physiological mechanisms by which deep sleep
naturally cleans the brain.
That opens an entirely new therapeutic
concept.
Rather than trying to remove
individual proteins such as amyloid with drugs, perhaps we can improve the
brain's own housekeeping system.
How the
intermittent CO₂ therapy was performed
The researchers did not expose
participants to continuous carbon dioxide. Instead, they used a carefully
controlled pattern of intermittent increase in the level of carbon
dioxide (CO₂) in the blood (hypercapnia). The hypercapnia was designed to
create rhythmic changes in cerebral blood flow.
Interestingly,
several studies have reported abnormalities in cerebral blood flow regulation
in autism, including reduced blood flow in specific brain regions and altered
responses of cerebral blood vessels to changing carbon dioxide levels. Since
the glymphatic system depends on rhythmic vascular pulsations to drive
cerebrospinal fluid through the brain, impaired vascular regulation could
potentially contribute to reduced glymphatic clearance.
Participants underwent three treatment
sessions, each lasting approximately 10 minutes, for a total treatment time of
about 30 minutes.
During each session they repeatedly
alternated between:
- 35 seconds breathing a gas mixture
containing 5% carbon dioxide
- 35 seconds breathing normal air
This cycle was repeated 24 times
across the three sessions. The sessions were performed during a single visit,
with short breaks between them.
The rationale was that the repeated
dilation and relaxation of cerebral blood vessels would generate slow vascular
oscillations similar to those that naturally occur during deep slow-wave sleep,
when the brain's glymphatic system is most active.
MRI scans demonstrated increased
cerebrospinal fluid movement through the brain, while blood tests showed
increased concentrations of several brain-derived proteins—including amyloid-β,
tau, GFAP and neurofilament light—in the circulation. The researchers
interpreted these findings as evidence of enhanced glymphatic clearance rather
than brain injury.
A new way of
thinking
Much autism research has focused on
inflammation, oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction and altered
neurotransmission.
But perhaps, in some autistic
individuals, these abnormalities are partly downstream consequences of impaired
brain waste clearance.
Instead of asking:
Which drug treats
autism?
perhaps we should also ask:
Can we restore
the brain's own housekeeping system?
That strategy might include:
- protecting deep sleep
- treating sleep disorders
- exercising regularly
- maintaining good cardiovascular health
- and perhaps one day therapies that
directly stimulate glymphatic flow
Looking ahead
This remains a hypothesis.
Neither the imaging studies nor the
intermittent hypercapnia study prove that improving glymphatic function will
improve autism symptoms.
However, taken together they suggest
something genuinely exciting.
For the first time we now have:
- evidence that glymphatic dysfunction is
present in autism,
- evidence that poorer glymphatic function
is associated with more severe communication difficulties,
- and evidence that the human glymphatic
system may be therapeutically stimulated.
That does not yet constitute a
treatment.
But it does provide the foundations
for an entirely new direction of autism research—one aimed not at treating
individual downstream abnormalities, but at restoring one of the brain's most
fundamental maintenance systems.
If this hypothesis proves correct, the
simplest interventions may remain among the most important: protect deep sleep,
exercise regularly, maintain good cardiovascular health, and treat sleep
disorders whenever possible. Future research will determine whether directly
stimulating glymphatic flow can add to these fundamental approaches.
While a variety of therapies are marketed as improving lymphatic drainage, there is currently no convincing evidence that they enhance glymphatic clearance in humans.
Which are some ways we can increase deep sleep? Everything we tried just doesn’t seem to be enough to get him past 3/4 hours of sleep. Melatonin, valerian, taurine, no lights and many others strategies that also failed like antihistamines. Dayvigo was tried for 2 days but makes next day drowsiness very hard to handle, half life for lamborexant seems to be very long lasting until next day.
ReplyDeleteYou can try glycine . My child doesnt have sleep issues but I was having it last year and it helped.
DeleteOmalizumab
DeleteThe initiation and maintenance of sleep involves a wide range of biological processes, many of which are associated with autism. As a result, about half of those with autism have some degree of sleep disorder, albeit of varying degree.
DeleteThere are a wide range of well-known OTC options, but there is a new generation of drugs called DORAs (dual orexin receptor antagonists) like the Dayvigo you tried. I think you will have better luck with Quviviq, or just a lower dose of Dayvigo. Dayvigo has a half-life of 18 hours whereas for Quviviq it is 8 hours. Some people taking Dayvigo will sleep fine but wake up with a hangover.
Clearly if you knew the biological pathway that was affecting sleep in your particular case, you could try and target it directly. This would not technically be a sleep drug, but it would improve sleep in your case. This is Stephen’s point.
For other readers, be aware that DORAs are expensive and their use in children is off-label.
The process of getting Quvivig approved for 10-18 year olds is ongoing.
If sleep remains poor despite treatments, it is important to look for underlying medical conditions that can disrupt sleep, such as sleep apnoea, restless legs syndrome or periodic limb movements, gastrointestinal problems (such as reflux or constipation), chronic pain, anxiety, or, where clinically indicated, epilepsy.
Omalizumab decreased my sons Leo and Stephen adenoids so it stop their obstructive sleep apnea. It beat doing surgery. :)
DeleteEffective treatment of a child with adenoidal hypertrophy and severe asthma by omalizumab: a case report
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13223-022-00732-9
I have autism and also periodic limb movement disorder, restless legs and insomnia all diagnosed as an adult when they got out of hand. I am on pregablin for PLMD and restless legs. In terms of sleep generally, this is yet another thing that transcranial photobiomodulation has really helped with. I have had the odd insomnia relapse but I have not required Zopiclone for over a year.
DeleteAfter reading the article here, I have to wonder how much of my autism is the result of untreated initial sleep issues from an early age. My mother tells me that I wasn't a great sleeper, even as a tiny baby. I also showed symptoms of all of the sleep problems listed from a young age.
It is striking how often sleep disorders seem to cluster together in autistic people. Restless legs syndrome, periodic limb movement disorder (PLMD) and insomnia can all fragment sleep without the person necessarily realizing just how disrupted it is.
DeleteIt is encouraging to hear that pregabalin has helped your PLMD and restless legs, and particularly interesting that transcranial photobiomodulation has improved your sleep enough that you have not needed zopiclone for over a year. These Z-drugs can become a mixed blessing, when people cannot sleep without them.
Regarding your question, I do not think the evidence supports the idea that untreated sleep problems cause autism. Rather, I think it is more likely that, in some children, the same underlying biology contributes to both autism and sleep disturbances from infancy. Poor sleep during critical periods of brain development may then amplify autistic symptoms or affect language, attention and learning, making the overall presentation more severe.
I think sleep deserves much more attention in autism. Unlike many aspects of autism, sleep problems are often treatable, and improving sleep can have surprisingly broad benefits for daytime behaviour, cognition and quality of life. Your experience is a good example of why clinicians should not dismiss sleep issues as just another feature of autism, but instead treat them as a worthwhile therapeutic target.
Peter, what is your sense of saunas for some groups? And what is your sense of saunas in general for say, deep sleep?
ReplyDeleteThat is an interesting question. There is reasonably good evidence that regular sauna use has general health benefits, including improvements in cardiovascular health, lower blood pressure, and reduced risks of cardiovascular disease and even dementia. However, those studies don't prove that the sauna itself is responsible, it can just be a social activity.
DeleteRegarding sleep, several small studies suggest that taking a sauna 1–3 hours before bedtime can improve subjective sleep quality and may increase deep (slow-wave) sleep. The proposed mechanism is that raising the body's core temperature, followed by cooling afterwards, reinforces the brain's normal sleep signals and makes it easier to enter deeper sleep.
Since deep sleep is when the glymphatic system is most active, it is plausible that anything which reliably increases slow-wave sleep could also enhance the brain's overnight waste-clearance system.
A sauna is one of several lifestyle interventions—alongside regular exercise, good sleep hygiene, and maintaining cardiovascular health—that may support healthy sleep and, indirectly, glymphatic function. It is unlikely to be a "magic bullet," but for people who enjoy it and have no medical contraindications, it is a reasonable habit with potential health benefits beyond sleep.
I think regular exercise is likely the most beneficial. If you live in Finland, you would do the exercise and then take the sauna!
I work for an intranasal device company that has the ability to bypass the blood brain barrier-this device has been used for over 10 years with tremendous success in preventing and keeping Alzheimer's and associated dementias from progressing. Dr. Shankle has a remarkable track record with combining Immunoglobins and insulin in clearing this cellular debris and dramatically. Reducing neuroinflammation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBDpluHlR1c&t=2s Here is his amazing interview discussing his theories. Kurve has had years of research available at this website. www.kurverearch.com Dr. Nicola Antonucci just spoke about some of the success he has had with patients using this protocol at the NeurAnova medical conference.
ReplyDeleteWhat about the effects of intermittent fasting on cell house keeping? My son who is mostly in ketosis skips breakfast now to have a decent fast overnight and it seems to suit him.
ReplyDeleteThat is a very relevant question in the context of our brain waste-management analogy.
DeleteAutophagy = cleaning inside cells
Glymphatic system = cleaning outside cells
Intermittent fasting and ketosis have been shown to activate autophagy, the process by which cells break down and recycle damaged proteins and worn-out cell components. Autophagy is essentially the cell's own internal housekeeping system, whereas the glymphatic system is the brain's waste-disposal system that clears material from the spaces between cells, particularly during deep sleep.
Although these are different processes, they are complementary. In theory, improving both intracellular housekeeping (autophagy) and extracellular waste clearance (the glymphatic system) could help maintain a healthier brain. However, there is currently no direct evidence that intermittent fasting enhances glymphatic function in humans.
If your son is comfortable with his eating pattern, is maintaining a healthy weight, and is meeting his nutritional needs, then an overnight fast of 12–16 hours is a perfectly reasonable approach. Ketogenic diets are already used therapeutically for epilepsy, and there is growing interest in their effects on brain metabolism and neurodegenerative diseases. Whether they improve autism through enhanced autophagy or through other mechanisms remains an open question.
What is becoming increasingly clear is that the brain has several complementary "housekeeping" systems. Deep sleep supports the glymphatic system, while fasting and ketosis appear to stimulate autophagy. Both are likely to be important for maintaining healthy brain function, even though we do not yet know how much they interact in humans.
Here is some more great information: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6wcvN7rgeM
ReplyDelete