The role of the microbiome in aggression. Gut microbe imbalances that predict autism and ADHD. Biogaia trial for Autism.

 

By December 2020 7.3% of the Swedish cohort born in 1997-9 had been diagnosed with a Neurodevelopmental Disorder (ND). This can be predicted by samples previously collected.

Today’s post is all about the microbiome and covers three different areas covered recently in the research. Eight years after I wrote a post about our informal trial of Biogaia probiotics for autism, we now have a published paper.

Aggression and self injurious behavior (SIB) affects at least half of those diagnosed with level 3 autism at some point in their lives. SIB can become the overriding concern for care givers.

Our first paper looks at the role of the microbiome in aggression.

Gut-brain axis appears to play a critical role in aggression

A series of experiments on mice has found that they become more aggressive when their gut microbiome is depleted. Additionally, transplanting gut microbiota from human infants exposed to antibiotics led to heightened aggression in mice compared to those receiving microbiome transplants from non-exposed infants. The research was published in Brain, Behavior, and Immunity.

In the past decade, scientists have discovered a complex communication pathway linking gut microbiota—the trillions of microorganisms living in the human gut—with the brain. This pathway is called the microbiota-gut-brain axis. It regulates various physiological functions, including digestion and immunity, but also affects mood and behavior. The gut microbiota produces neurotransmitters and other metabolites that can influence brain function through neural, immune, and endocrine pathways.

Recent studies have demonstrated that symptoms of various disorders, once considered primarily psychological or neurological, can be transferred to rodents by transplanting gut microbiota from humans with these disorders. For example, researchers have shown that transplanting gut microorganisms from people with Alzheimer’s disease into mice (whose gut microbiota had been depleted to enhance transplant effectiveness) resulted in cognitive impairments in the mice. Similarly, symptoms of anxiety have been induced in mice by transplanting gut microbiota from humans with social anxiety.

For the humanized mice, the researchers obtained fecal samples from infants who had been exposed to antibiotics shortly after birth, as well as from unexposed infants. These samples were transplanted into five-week-old germ-free mice. The researchers then waited for four weeks before testing the mice for aggression.

To measure aggression, the researchers employed the resident-intruder test, a well-established behavioral assay in which a male mouse (the “resident”) is introduced to another unfamiliar male mouse (the “intruder”) in its home cage. Aggression was quantified based on the latency to the first attack (how quickly the resident mouse attacked the intruder) and the total number of attacks during a 10-minute period.

The results showed that mice raised without gut bacteria (germ-free) and those treated with antibiotics exhibited higher levels of aggression compared to the control group. These mice attacked more frequently and were quicker to initiate aggressive behavior in the resident-intruder test.

The researchers found that humanized mice receiving fecal microbiota from antibiotic-exposed infants were significantly more aggressive than those receiving transplants from non-exposed infants. Even though the infants’ microbiomes had a month to recover after antibiotic exposure, the aggressive behavior was still evident in the recipient mice.

Biochemical analyses revealed that aggressive mice (both germ-free and antibiotic-treated) had distinct metabolite profiles compared to control mice. Specifically, levels of tryptophan—a precursor to serotonin, a neurotransmitter associated with mood and behavior—were elevated in these mice. Additionally, the levels of certain metabolites associated with microbial activity, such as indole-3-lactic acid, were reduced in the aggressive mice, suggesting that the absence of a healthy microbiome might alter key biochemical pathways involved in aggression.

Here is the link to the original paper:

A gut reaction? The role of the microbiome in aggression

Recent research has unveiled conflicting evidence regarding the link between aggression and the gut microbiome. Here, we compared behavior profiles of control, germ-free (GF), and antibiotic-treated mice, as well as re-colonized GF mice to understand the impact of the gut microbiome on aggression using the resident-intruder paradigm. Our findings revealed a link between gut microbiome depletion and higher aggression, accompanied by notable changes in urine metabolite profiles and brain gene expression. This study extends beyond classical murine models to humanized mice to reveal the clinical relevance of early-life antibiotic use on aggression. Fecal microbiome transplant from infants exposed to antibiotics in early life (and sampled one month later) into mice led to increased aggression compared to mice receiving transplants from unexposed infants. This study sheds light on the role of the gut microbiome in modulating aggression and highlights its potential avenues of action, offering insights for development of therapeutic strategies for aggression-related disorders

Note the ABX means antibiotics

We include a study of humanized mice using unique fecal samples of 1-month-old infants, collected nearly a month after early-life ABX administration. In previous work (Uzan-Yulzari et al. 2021, Nat Comm), we have demonstrated that ABX in this critical period of life can have lasting effects of childhood growth. Here, we extend these findings using samples from the same cohort. Using fecal samples collected weeks after ABX administration also reduces the direct chemical effects of ABX on the host, highlighting the causative role of the dysbiotic host microbiome and associated metabolome in driving aggressive behavior. We demonstrate that infant microbiota, perturbed within the first 48 h of life, has a lasting signature through 1 month of age that, when transplanted into GF mice, results in increased aggression (3–5 weeks after transplant) when compared to effects of stools of infants not exposed to any early-life antibiotics. The findings are revolutionary as they show how ABX-altered microbiota during a critical development window can lead to persisting behavioral deficits.

 

Gut microbe imbalances could predict a child’s risk for autism, ADHD and speech disorders years before symptoms appear.

Study Identifies Gut Microbe Imbalances That Predict Autism And ADHD

We are researchers who study the role the microbiome plays in a variety of conditions, such as mental illness, autoimmunity, obesity, preterm birth and others. In our recently published research on Swedish children, we found that microbes and the metabolites they produce in the guts of infants – both found in poop and cord blood – could help screen for a child’s risk of neurodevelopmental conditions such as autism. And these differences can be detected as early as birth or within the first year of life. These markers were evident, on average, over a decade before the children were diagnosed. 

The imbalance in microbial composition – what microbiologists call dysbiosis – we observed suggests that incomplete recovery from repeated antibiotic use may greatly affect children during this vulnerable period. Similarly, we saw that repeated ear infections were linked to a twofold increased likelihood of developing autism.

Children who both repeatedly used antibiotics and had microbial imbalances were significantly more likely to develop autism. More specifically, children with an absence of Coprococcus comes, a bacterium linked to mental health and quality of life, and increased prevalence of Citrobacter, a bacterium known for antimicrobial resistance, along with repeated antibiotic use were two to four times more likely to develop a neurodevelopmental disorder.

Antibiotics are necessary for treating certain bacterial infections in children, and we emphasize that our findings do not suggest avoiding their use altogether. Parents should use antibiotics if they are prescribed and deemed necessary by their pediatrician. Rather, our study suggests that repeated antibiotic use during early childhood may signal underlying immune dysfunction or disrupted brain development, which can be influenced by the gut microbiome. In any case, it is important to consider whether children could benefit from treatments to restore their gut microbes after taking antibiotics, an area we are actively studying.

Another microbial imbalance in children who later were diagnosed with neurodevelopmental disorders was a decrease in Akkermansia muciniphila, a bacterium that reinforces the lining of the gut and is linked to neurotransmitters important to neurological health.

Even after we accounted for factors that could influence gut microbe composition, such as how the baby was delivered and breastfeeding, the relationship between imbalanced bacteria and future diagnosis persisted. And these imbalances preceded diagnosis of autism, ADHD or intellectual disability by 13 to 14 years on average, refuting the assumption that gut microbe imbalances arise from diet.

We found that lipids and bile acids were depleted in the cord blood of newborns with future autism. These compounds provide nutrients for beneficial bacteria, help maintain immune balance and influence neurotransmitter systems and signaling pathways in the brain.

The full paper is here: 

Infant microbes and metabolites point to childhood neurodevelopmental disorders 

Highlights

• Infant microbes and metabolites differentiate controls and future NDs

• Early-life otitis lowers Coprococcus and increases Citrobacter in future NDs

• Preterm birth, infection, stress, parental smoking, and HLA DR4-DQ8 increase ND risk

• Linolenic acid is lower and PFDA toxins higher in the cord serum of future ASD

Summary

This study has followed a birth cohort for over 20 years to find factors associated with neurodevelopmental disorder (ND) diagnosis. Detailed, early-life longitudinal questionnaires captured infection and antibiotic events, stress, prenatal factors, family history, and more. Biomarkers including cord serum metabolome and lipidome, human leukocyte antigen (HLA) genotype, infant microbiota, and stool metabolome were assessed. Among the 16,440 Swedish children followed across time, 1,197 developed an ND. Significant associations emerged for future ND diagnosis in general and for specific ND subtypes, spanning intellectual disability, speech disorder, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, and autism. This investigation revealed microbiome connections to future diagnosis as well as early emerging mood and gastrointestinal problems. The findings suggest links to immune-dysregulation and metabolism, compounded by stress, early-life infection, and antibiotics. The convergence of infant biomarkers and risk factors in this prospective, longitudinal study on a large-scale population establishes a foundation for early-life prediction and intervention in neurodevelopment.

ABIS = All Babies in Southeast Sweden cohort

NDs = Neurodevelopmental disorders

Young children later diagnosed with ASD or exhibiting significant autistic traits tend to experience more ear and upper respiratory symptoms. In ABIS, infants who had otitis in their first year were found to be more prone to acquiring NDs if they lacked detectable levels of Coprococcus or harbored Citrobacter. The absence of Coprococcus, despite comparable levels in controls irrespective of otitis, raises questions about microbial community recovery. This potential failure of the microbiome to recover following such events may serve as a mechanism connecting otitis media to ND risk. Moreover, antibiotic-resistant Citrobacter was more prevalent in these infants. The presence of strains related  to Salmonella and Citrobacter, labeled in this investigation as SREB, was significantly higher in infants who later developed comorbid ASD/ADHD (21%), compared to controls (3%). This disruption may have consequences on neurodevelopment during a critical period. Salmonella and Citrobacter have shown the ability to upregulate the Wingless (Wnt) signaling. The Wnt pathway is vital for immune dysregulation and brain development, and its disruption has been implicated in ASD pathogenesis. 

Two fatty acid differences were notable in the stool of future ASD versus controls: omega-7 monounsaturated palmitoleic acid, (9Z)-hexadec-9-enoic acid (below the level of detection in 87.0% of future ASD but present in 43.5% of controls), and palmitic acid (elevated in future ASD). Palmitoleic acid has been associated with a decreased risk of islet and primary insulin autoimmunity. Conversely, palmitic acid, a saturated fatty acid, has been linked to neuronal homeostasis interference. Its effects are partially protected by oleic acid, which although approaching significance, was lower in the cord serum of future ASD.

Few metabolites were higher in stool of infants with future ASD, but there are a few notable examples: α-d-glucose, pyruvate, and 3-isopropylmalate. Coprococcus inversely correlated with 3-isopropylmalate, suggesting gut-brain connections and a possible imbalance in branched-chain amino acid (BCAA) pathways given the role of 3-isopropylmalate dehydrogenase in leucine and isoleucine biosynthesis. An increase in dehydroascorbate suggests potential disruptions in vitamin C metabolism, crucial for neurotransmitter synthesis and antioxidant defense, while elevated pyruvate suggests disturbance of neurotransmitter synthesis or energy production early in life. Pimelic acid elevation, found in disorders of fatty acid oxidation, suggests disruption of mitochondrial pathways for fatty acid oxidation.

Akkermansia and Coprococcus, absent or reduced in infants with future NDs, positively correlated with signals in stool representing neurotransmitter precursors and essential vitamins in stool. Specifically, Akkermansia correlated with tyrosine and tryptophan (i.e., catecholamine and serotonin precursors, respectively) and Coprococcus with riboflavin. Disruption of BCAA metabolism in ASD has been documented, involving coding variants in large amino acid transporters (LATs) and reduced utilization of trypotphan and large aromatic amino acids along with increased glutamate and decreases in tyrosine, isoleucine, phenylalanine, and tryptophan in children with ASD. Oxidative stress, a diminished capacity for efficient energy transport, and deficiencies in vitamins (like vitamin B2) essential for neurotransmitter synthesis and nerve cell maintenance have been implicated. Riboflavin as an antioxidant reduces oxidative stress and inflammation, demonstrating neuroprotective benefits in neurological disorders, possibly through maintenance of vitamin B6, which is necessary for glutamate conversion to glutamine and 5-hydroxytryptophan to serotonin.

Together, these findings support a hypothesis of early-life origins of NDs, mediated by gut microbiota. This provides a foundation for research and for developing early interventions for NDs.

 

Today’s final paper was highlighted recently in a comment on a post I wrote eight years ago, when we were trialing Biogaia probiotics. This original interest was prompted by a reader sharing her successful experiences of treating her son with severe autism. Perhaps she left the recent comment?

The two bacteria involved are both types of L. reuteri.

L. reuteri 6475 is sold as Biogaia Osfortis

L. reuteri 17938 is sold Biogaia Protectis

The combination of L. reuteri 17938 and L. reuteri 6475 is sold as Biogaia Gastrus.

My old post from 2016:-

Epiphany: Biogaia Trial for Inflammatory Autism Subtypes

The recently published trial:

Precision microbial intervention improves social behavior but not autism severity: A pilot double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trial -

Highlights

• L. reuteri (6475 + 17938) improves social functioning in children with autism

• L. reuteri does not improve overall autism severity or repetitive behaviors

• L. reuteri does not significantly alter microbiome composition or immune profile

•  Only the 6475 strain reverses the social deficits in a mouse model for autism

we performed a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled, parallel-design pilot trial in children with ASD. Importantly, we found that L. reuteri, compared with placebo, significantly improved social functioning, both in terms of reducing social deficits, as measured by the social responsiveness scale (SRS^31,32), and increasing adaptive social functioning, as measured by the social adaptive composite score of the Adaptive Behavior Assessment System, Second Edition (ABAS-2³³). L. reuteri did not improve overall autism severity, restricted and repetitive behaviors, and co-occurring psychiatric and behavioral problems, nor did it significantly modulate the microbiome or immune response. Thus, this safe microbial manipulation has the potential for improving social deficits associated with ASD in children.

I had to amend my old post with a warning long ago.

UPDATE: A significant minority of parents report negative reaction to Bio Gaia, this seems to relate to histamine; but more than 50% report very positive effects without any side effects; so best to try a very small dose initially to see if it is not well tolerated. 

Histamine Reaction to BioGaia gastrus

Conclusion

The gut microbiota does indeed play a key role in how your brain functions, but the gut-brain axis works in both directions. What goes on in your brain can affect your gut and not just the other way around. It is called bidirectional signaling.

Antibiotics taken during pregnancy, or during early childhood, will have unintended consequences. Often there is no choice, like for those readers whose baby experienced sepsis at birth (bacterial blood stream infection); you have to give antibiotics to avoid death.

In today’s second paper we see that the researchers are thinking about therapeutical implications. Perhaps the newborn’s gut flora should be repopulated during the weeks after the antibiotic treatment?

I receive many questions about how to treat self injurious behavior that does not respond to anything the doctor has prescribed. Rifaximin, an antibiotic used to treat irritable bowel syndrome with diarrhea, is one therapy that does help some types of SIB (and SIBO, small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, of course). This probably would not surprise the authors of today’s first paper.

Biogaia Gastrus (L. reuteri 6475 + 17938) from today’s third paper worked wonders for the SIB of one reader’s child.

Not surprisingly fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) can improve SIB in some people.

The Swedish data shows interesting insights such as that lipids and bile acids were depleted in the cord blood of newborns with future autism. The researchers think they can predict the diagnosis of autism or ADHD. The question is and then what? Even when there is a diagnosis of autism, not much changes for most children.

Is it safe to treat autism in very young children? Plus, the impact of impaired autophagy on cognition and treating SIB

This blog is full of clinical trials that use existing drugs that are repurposed to treat autism. One constant issue is whether the trial drug is free from side effects. Generally speaking side effects tend not to be a problem, but there always can be exceptions.

I was recently contacted by the parents of a two year old with a single gene (monogenic) type of autism and they want to treat their child to improve his outcome.  This is the youngest case I have encountered.

With monogenic autisms you often have clear indications from a very early age that something unusual is present. Once you have a diagnosis you quickly discover what issues the child is going to face. You therefore have a good idea of what will happen if you do nothing. Some other two year olds have delayed speech and other signs of autism, but within a couple of years develop normally – it was a case of delayed maturation.

I noted long ago that American autism doctors tend to want to treat younger patients with supplements rather than drugs.

The reality is that the sooner you start to correct a severe biological dysfunction the better the outcome will be. We even see that some treatments are only effective if given to toddlers. This makes perfect sense although it may be uncomfortable to accept.

I was looking for supporting evidence for very early intervention. I found a glowing report of the treatment of a 2 year old with Fragile X syndrome using Metformin. I am amazed Fragile X still remains untreated in most cases.

On examination at age 2 years, typical physical features of FXS were observed, and baseline laboratory findings were normal (see Table Table1).1). He was started on metformin at 25 mg of the liquid form that is 100 mg/ml at dinner, and his dose was gradually increased to 200 mg twice a day (bid) over 1 year (see Table Table1).1). After initiation of metformin, his sleep disturbance resolved, only occasionally awakening once for roughly 30 min. Two weeks after initiation, he went from stacking 3–4 blocks to stacking a tower of 11 or more blocks; within a few more weeks, he began building more complex structures comprised of different size blocks. He showed marked improvement in self‐help and motor activities, including toilet training, clearing the table and loading the dishwasher, brushing his own teeth, dressing independently, and learning how to make toast. His preschool teachers, who were unaware of metformin treatment, told his mother that “it's like something just clicked or he just woke up. He's a whole different kid.”

Source: Metformin treatment in young children with fragile X syndrome

Some drugs including bumetanide are already safely given to babies.

Nonetheless, it is a brave step to start treatment in a two year old. I did connect the parents to a reader of this blog whose child has the same syndrome but is a few years older.

Today’s post was prompted by the news that the child is already showing improvements from the first therapy, which is a small dose of clemastine. In this syndrome there is a mutation in TCF4 and there is impaired myelination and very likely activated microglia (the brain’s immune cells). The near immediate beneficial effect cannot be on myelination, but it could be resetting microglia to the resting state.

Other genes very recently raised have been TRIT1 and PSMB9; neither of these are classed as autism genes, but evidently can cause it. Mutations in TRIT1 cause a problem in the mitochondria and PSMB9 mutations cause the immune system to misbehave.  It looks like both can lead to an autism diagnosis.

A common issue parents encounter is that often the interest shown by researchers and clinicians stops at the point of diagnosis. What really matters is what to do next. Only very rarely will such “experts” suggest what to do next. 

It looks like there nearly always are therapeutic avenues to pursue after such a diagnosis. It should be noted that even in single gene (monogenic) autisms there are varying levels of response to the same therapy. We saw this a while back with the new FDA approved therapy for Rett syndrome – it works for some, but not for others.

 

Treating self injurious behavior (SIB) in idiopathic autism

I recently received feedback from several parents who have had success in treating SIB based on ideas in this blog.

Verapamil came up again as successful.

Pioglitazone, at a low dose of 7.5mg, was the game changer for one child.

Ibuprofen worked in another case, but this cannot be used long term. Celecoxib should be better tolerated and in theory should be as effective. Time will tell.

More people are trying the add-on therapy of a small dose of taurine.

 

Macroautophagy as a cause of impaired cognition

Impaired autophagy came up recently in two people’s genetic testing results. There is a lot in this blog about autophagy and dementia/mild cognitive impairment.

Today we have a paper that links impaired autophagy with impaired cognition.

Twenty years ago severe autism generally also meant impaired cognition. Nowadays it does not; you can have severe autism with normal cognition.

There are various different types of autophagy but in general it is all about collecting bits of cellular garbage that might clog things up. As we get older this intracellular garbage collection process works less well and then diseases like Alzheimer’s follow decades later.

Impaired autophagy may contribute to impaired cognition at any age. Most research concerns dementia treatment, or other conditions affecting older people like Huntington’s disease.

There is little focus on younger populations, even though we know that children with Down syndrome are prone to get early onset Alzheimer’s. Treating young people with Down syndrome to improve autophagy might bring both short and long term benefits. 

Here is the recent paper on this subject. 

Impaired macroautophagy confers substantial risk for intellectual disability in children with autism spectrum disorders

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) represents a complex of neurological and developmental disabilities characterized by clinical and genetic heterogeneity. While the causes of ASD are still unknown, many ASD risk factors are found to converge on intracellular quality control mechanisms that are essential for cellular homeostasis, including the autophagy-lysosomal degradation pathway. Studies have reported impaired autophagy in ASD human brain and ASD-like synapse pathology and behaviors in mouse models of brain autophagy deficiency, highlighting an essential role for defective autophagy in ASD pathogenesis. To determine whether altered autophagy in the brain may also occur in peripheral cells that might provide useful biomarkers, we assessed activities of autophagy in lymphoblasts from ASD and control subjects. We find that lymphoblast autophagy is compromised in a subset of ASD participants due to impaired autophagy induction. Similar changes in autophagy are detected in postmortem human brains from ASD individuals and in brain and peripheral blood mononuclear cells from syndromic ASD mouse models. Remarkably, we find a strong correlation between impaired autophagy and intellectual disability in ASD participants. By depleting the key autophagy gene Atg7 from different brain cells, we provide further evidence that autophagy deficiency causes cognitive impairment in mice. Together, our findings suggest autophagy dysfunction as a convergent mechanism that can be detected in peripheral blood cells from a subset of autistic individuals, and that lymphoblast autophagy may serve as a biomarker to stratify ASD patients for the development of targeted interventions.

 

There are different types of autophagy and there are some overlaps. 

·      mTOR dependent (Fasting or Rapamycin)

·      AMPK dependent (Spermidine)

·      P53 dependent (no simple therapies)

·      Calcium signalling dependent (Verapamil)

The OTC way to increase autophagy is to use Spermidine, which is made from wheat germ or rice germ. Studies in humans are rather mixed and I think the dose is likely far too low. Supplements tend to contain about 1mg; I suspect you need much more to have an impact. You can indeed grow your own wheat sprouts which are highly nutritious and a rich source of spermidine. You can eat them raw or even in smoothies. 100 g of sprouts contains 10-15mg of spermidine.

The most researched calcium channel drug to induce autophagy is Verapamil, from my son’s original autism Polypill.

My takeaway continues to be to look for convergent mechanisms, like impaired autophagy, myelination, microglial activation etc that commonly occur in severe autism, of any origin. You then try and treat these likely dysfunctions rather than getting overly focused on individual genes.

 

Taurine – a cheap Autism intervention worth a trial

 

I did recently write a post all about Taurine and the many effects it has on the body, some of which really should affect autism. 

Taurine for subgroups of Autism? Plus, vitamin B5 and L Carnitine for KAT6A syndrome?

 

Having read the literature, it looked to me that anyone over 50 years old is likely to benefit from a little extra Taurine, but it certainly was not clear whether it would make my 21 year old’s autism better or worse. I went ahead and ordered some to investigate.

In theory one of the many effects of Taurine is negative. Taurine does affect the KCC2 transporter that takes chloride out of neurons the “wrong” way. The other effects include on calcium homeostasis, which we know is disturbed in most autism.

 

N = 2 Trial

Subject #1 (Peter)

I took 2g a day for a month and noticed no effect at all, other than some mild GI irritation.

In adults the long-term effects are numerous and varied throughout the body. Even the cells that remodel your bones (osteoblasts and osteoclasts) have special taurine transporters, whose sole role is to let taurine inside – taurine makes the osteoblasts work harder, while encouraging osteoclasts to take a break. The net effect should be stronger bones.  As you get older your natural levels of taurine fall substantially. There are taurine-rich foods you can eat and if you engage in strenuous exercise your liver starts making more taurine.

 

Subject #2 (Monty)

There is a clear contradiction when it comes to Taurine and sleep. Many energy drinks contain Taurine to keep you alert, but in theory Taurine should be calming and many people take it add bedtime to improve sleep.

Monty, aged 21 with ASD, likes getting up early and going to bed early.

Adding 2g a day of Taurine at breakfast shifted his circadian rhythms, so that he now goes to bed at a time typical for a 21 year old, but still wants to get up at 7am. Monty even fell asleep on the sofa watching TV late one night, something big brother often does. Indeed, Monty received a nod of approval when big brother discovered him in the early hours. 

The most beneficial change has been on his spring and summertime aggression. This has been controlled for years using an L-type calcium channel blocker. This does not resolve the allergy at all, but it “switches off” the consequential anxiety/aggression. With the addition of allergy therapies and the immunomodulation of Pioglitazone (in peak allergy season) the problem behaviors are controlled.

It appears that Taurine has a similar anti-anxiety/aggression effect. Maybe its effect on calcium channels and broader calcium homeostasis is the reason why. Anyway, it works – simple, cheap, OTC and effective.  It has no effect on allergy, in case you are wondering.

  

Conclusion

Taurine can be bought as a bulk powder for very little money. It is not like those numerous expensive supplements that would cost you several hundred dollars/euros/pounds a year.

If you have your own “healthspan polytherapy”, to ward off high blood pressure, high cholesterol, type 2 diabetes, dementia, arthritis, osteoporosis etc, consider spending a few pennies more and add a scoop of taurine.

The people who write to me and tell me how Verapamil has transformed life at home, by banishing aggression and self-injurious behaviors, should seriously consider a trial of Taurine.

 

Maternal Agmatine or Choline to prevent autism? International brain pH project. Androgen levels in autism spectrum disorders. Apigenin works for BTBR mice. Auditory hypersensitivity, myelin and Nav1.2 channels. Dopamine transporter binding abnormalities and self-injury

 

Shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted

Today’s post is a summary of what I found interesting in the latest research.  Many items have been touched on previously.

The topic of maternal treatment to prevent future autism did come up in some recent comments on this blog. Two of the recent papers cover this very subject. One uses agmatine, from my autism PolyPill therapy, while the other used choline.

Auditory sound sensitivity is a complex subject and today we see the potential role impaired myelination and Nav1.2 ion channels can play.

A Chinese study reconfirms the elevated level of androgen hormones in autism.  

Apigenin which was covered in an earlier post is shown to help “autistic” mice in the popular BTBR model. This is a model where the corpus callosum is entirely absent.

Self-injury is a recuring nightmare for many with severe autism and today we look at a possible correlation with dopamine transporter binding abnormalities.

We start with easier subject matter and leave the hard parts for later in the post.

Preventing future autism

It may seem like too late to be talking about preventing autism, but it is a recurring subject. Today we have two new ideas that have appeared in the literature, and both are very simple. One is choline and other agmatine; both are used in the treatment of already existing autism.

 

Maternal choline to prevent autism

“maternal choline supplementation may be sufficient to blunt some of the behavioral and neurobiological impacts of inflammatory exposures in utero, indicating that it may be a cheap, safe, and effective intervention for neurodevelopmental disorders.” 

 

Maternal choline supplementation modulates cognition and induces anti-inflammatory signaling in the prefrontal cortex of adolescent rats exposed to maternal immune activation

Maternal infection has long been described as a risk factor for neurodevelopmental disorders, especially autism spectrum disorders (ASD) and schizophrenia. Although many pathogens do not cross the placenta and infect the developing fetus directly, the maternal immune response to them is sufficient to alter fetal neurodevelopment, a phenomenon termed maternal immune activation (MIA). Low maternal choline is also a risk factor for neurodevelopmental disorders, and most pregnant people do not receive enough of it. In addition to its role in neurodevelopment, choline is capable of inducing anti-inflammatory signaling through a nicotinic pathway. Therefore, it was hypothesized that maternal choline supplementation would blunt the neurodevelopmental impact of MIA in offspring through long- term instigation of cholinergic anti-inflammatory signaling.

To model MIA in rats, the viral mimetic polyinosinic:polycytidylic acid (poly(I:C)) was used to elicit a maternal antiviral innate immune response in dams both with and without choline supplementation. Offspring were reared to both early and late adolescent stages (postnatal days 28 and 50, respectively), where cognition and anxiety-related behaviors were examined. After behavioral testing, animals were euthanized, and their prefrontal cortices (PFCs) were collected for analysis. MIA offspring demonstrated sex-specific patterns of altered cognition and repetitive behaviors, which were modulated by maternal choline supplementation. Choline supplementation also bolstered anti-inflammatory signaling in the PFCs of MIA animals at both early and late adolescent stages. These findings suggest that maternal choline supplementation may be sufficient to blunt some of the behavioral and neurobiological impacts of inflammatory exposures in utero, indicating that it may be a cheap, safe, and effective intervention for neurodevelopmental disorders.

 

Prenatal Agmatine to prevent autism

Agmatine is a cheap bodybuilder supplement also used in psychiatry that has been extensively covered in this blog. Here we see how in a popular mouse model it can prevent autism.

The prenatal use of agmatine prevents social behavior deficits in VPA-exposed mice by activating the ERK/CREB/BDNF signaling pathway

Background: According to reports, prenatal exposure to valproic acid can induce autism spectrum disorder (ASD)-like symptoms in both humans and rodents. However, the exact cause and therapeutic method of ASD is not fully understood. Agmatine (AGM) is known for its neuroprotective effects, and this study aims to explore whether giving agmatine hydrochloride before birth can prevent autism-like behaviors in mouse offspring exposed prenatally to valproic acid.

Methods: In this study, we investigated the effects of AGM prenatally on valproate (VPA)-exposed mice. We established a mouse model of ASD by prenatally administering VPA. From birth to weaning, we evaluated mouse behavior using the marble burying test, open-field test, and three-chamber social interaction test on male offspring.

Results: The results showed prenatal use of AGM relieved anxiety and hyperactivity behaviors as well as ameliorated sociability of VPA-exposed mice in the marble burying test, open-field test, and three-chamber social interaction test, and this protective effect might be attributed to the activation of the ERK/CREB/BDNF signaling pathway.

Conclusion: Therefore, AGM can effectively reduce the likelihood of offspring developing autism to a certain extent when exposed to VPA during pregnancy, serving as a potential therapeutic drug.

This builds on an earlier paper that first identified the benefit.

 

Agmatine rescues autistic behaviors in the valproic acid-induced animal model of autism

  

Highlights

•                  Single treatment of agmatine rescues social impairment in the VPA-induced animal model of autism.

•                  Effect of agmatine in social improvement in the VPA model is induced from agmatine itself, not its metabolite.

•                  Agmatine rescues repetitive and hyperactive behavior, and seizure susceptibility in the VPA model.

•                  Overly activated ERK1/2 in the brain of the VPA model is relieved by agmatine.

 

Apigenin

50mg of Apigenin

1g of dried parsley
15-20g of dried chamomile flowers

 

I have previously written about Apigenin, which is an OTC supplement. There has been another paper recently published about it. There is a logical connection with the maternal choline therapy from above.

 

What does Apigenin have in common with Choline?  α7-nAChRs

Choline is interesting because it acts as both a precursor for acetylcholine synthesis and it is a neuromodulator itself.

Choline is activates α7-nAChRs, alpha-7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptors.

These receptors are extremely important in learning and sensory processing.  They also play a key role in inflammation and signaling via the vagus nerve.

Apigenin is a flavonoid found in many plants, fruits, and vegetables. It has been shown to have a number of health benefits, including anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects. Apigenin has also been shown to interact with α7-nAChRs.

Studies have shown that apigenin can:

Enhance α7-nAChR function: Apigenin has been shown to increase the activity of α7-nAChRs. This may be due to its ability to bind to a specific site on the receptor.

Protect α7-nAChRs from damage: Apigenin may also help to protect α7-nAChRs from damage caused by oxidative stress.

 

Apigenin Alleviates Autistic-like Stereotyped Repetitive Behaviors and Mitigates Brain Oxidative Stress in Mice

Studying the involvement of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs), specifically α7-nAChRs, in neuropsychiatric brain disorders such as autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has gained a growing interest. The flavonoid apigenin (APG) has been confirmed in its pharmacological action as a positive allosteric modulator of α7-nAChRs. However, there is no research describing the pharmacological potential of APG in ASD. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of the subchronic systemic treatment of APG (10–30 mg/kg) on ASD-like repetitive and compulsive-like behaviors and oxidative stress status in the hippocampus and cerebellum in BTBR mice, utilizing the reference drug aripiprazole (ARP, 1 mg/kg, i.p.). BTBR mice pretreated with APG (20 mg/kg) or ARP (1 mg/g, i.p.) displayed significant improvements in the marble-burying test (MBT), cotton-shredding test (CST), and self-grooming test (SGT) (all p < 0.05). However, a lower dose of APG (10 mg/kg, i.p.) failed to modulate behaviors in the MBT or SGT, but significantly attenuated the increased shredding behaviors in the CST of tested mice. Moreover, APG (10–30 mg/kg, i.p.) and ARP (1 mg/kg) moderated the disturbed levels of oxidative stress by mitigating the levels of catalase (CAT) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) in the hippocampus and cerebellum of treated BTBR mice. In patch clamp studies in hippocampal slices, the potency of choline (a selective agonist of α7-nAChRs) in activating fast inward currents was significantly potentiated following incubation with APG. Moreover, APG markedly potentiated the choline-induced enhancement of spontaneous inhibitory postsynaptic currents. The observed results propose the potential therapeutic use of APG in the management of ASD. However, further preclinical investigations in additional models and different rodent species are still needed to confirm the potential relevance of the therapeutic use of APG in ASD.

  

Altered acidity (pH) levels inside the brain

I found it intriguing that a large study has examined the altered acidity (pH) levels inside the brain of those with neurological disorders.

For all the disorders other than autism there was a clear pattern of low pH, which means increased acidity.

For autism certain autism models exhibited decreased pH and increased lactate levels, but others showed the opposite pattern, reflecting subpopulations within autism.

Altered brain energy metabolism is an acknowledged feature of autism, so we should not be surprised to find altered levels of acidity.

The easy reading version:

 

Brain Acidity Linked With Multiple Neurological Disorders

 

The study itself:

Large-scale animal model study uncovers altered brain pH and lactate levels as a transdiagnostic endophenotype of neuropsychiatric disorders involving cognitive impairment

Increased levels of lactate, an end-product of glycolysis, have been proposed as a potential surrogate marker for metabolic changes during neuronal excitation. These changes in lactate levels can result in decreased brain pH, which has been implicated in patients with various neuropsychiatric disorders. We previously demonstrated that such alterations are commonly observed in five mouse models of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and autism, suggesting a shared endophenotype among these disorders rather than mere artifacts due to medications or agonal state. However, there is still limited research on this phenomenon in animal models, leaving its generality across other disease animal models uncertain. Moreover, the association between changes in brain lactate levels and specific behavioral abnormalities remains unclear. To address these gaps, the International Brain pH Project Consortium investigated brain pH and lactate levels in 109 strains/conditions of 2,294 animals with genetic and other experimental manipulations relevant to neuropsychiatric disorders. Systematic analysis revealed that decreased brain pH and increased lactate levels were common features observed in multiple models of depression, epilepsy, Alzheimer’s disease, and some additional schizophrenia models. While certain autism models also exhibited decreased pH and increased lactate levels, others showed the opposite pattern, potentially reflecting subpopulations within the autism spectrum. Furthermore, utilizing large-scale behavioral test battery, a multivariate cross-validated prediction analysis demonstrated that poor working memory performance was predominantly associated with increased brain lactate levels. Importantly, this association was confirmed in an independent cohort of animal models. Collectively, these findings suggest that altered brain pH and lactate levels, which could be attributed to dysregulated excitation/inhibition balance, may serve as transdiagnostic endophenotypes of debilitating neuropsychiatric disorders characterized by cognitive impairment, irrespective of their beneficial or detrimental nature.

In conclusion, the present study demonstrated that altered brain pH and lactate levels are commonly observed in animal models of SZ, BD, ID, ASD, AD, and other neuropsychiatric disorders. These findings provide further evidence supporting the hypothesis that altered brain pH and lactate levels are not mere artifacts, such as those resulting from medication confounding, but are rather involved in the underlying pathophysiology of some patients with neuropsychiatric disorders. Altered brain energy metabolism or neural hyper- or hypoactivity leading to abnormal lactate levels and pH may serve as a potential therapeutic targets for neuropsychiatric disorders

 

Why would the brain be acidic (reduced pH)?

To function optimally mitochondria need adequate oxygen and glucose. When performance is impaired, for example due to the lack of Complex 1, mitochondria switch from OXPHOS (oxidative phosphorylation) to fermentation to produce energy (ATP). Lactic acid is the byproduct and this will lower pH.

 

Does brain pH matter?

It does matter and is linked to cognitive impairments, headaches, seizures etc.

Many enzymes in the brain rely on a specific pH range to function properly. Deviations from the ideal pH can hinder their activity, impacting various neurochemical processes essential for brain function.

Some ion channels are pH sensitive.

 

Chemical buffers in the brain aim to regulate pH in the brain

·       Carbonic Acid/Bicarbonate Buffer System: Similar to the blood, the brain utilizes this system to regulate pH.

·   Organic Phosphates: These molecules, like creatine phosphate, can act as buffers in the brain by binding or releasing hydrogen ions.

These buffering systems work together to maintain a tightly controlled pH range in both the blood (around 7.35-7.45) and the brain (slightly more acidic than blood, around 7.0-7.3). Even slight deviations from this ideal range can have significant consequences for cellular function.

  

Androgen Levels in Autism

Androgens are male hormones like testosterone, DHEA and DHT, but females have them too, just at lower levels.

Drugs that reduce the level of these hormones are called antiandrogens.

Finasteride reduces DHT and is used to treat hair loss in men as Propecia. This drug was trialed in women, but failed to show a benefit over the placebo.

The main use of Finasteride is for the treatment of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) in older men.

Women sometimes take antiandrogens like Spironolactone to control acne.

Numerous studies have show elevated levels of males hormones in both males and females with autism.

A recent paper was published on this very subject: 

Androgen levels in autism spectrum disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Background:

Accumulating evidence suggests that the autism spectrum disorder (ASD) population exhibits altered hormone levels, including androgens. However, studies on the regulation of androgens, such as testosterone and dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA), in relation to sex differences in individuals with ASD are limited and inconsistent. We conducted the systematic review with meta-analysis to quantitatively summarise the blood, urine, or saliva androgen data between individuals with ASD and controls.

Methods:

A systematic search was conducted for eligible studies published before 16 January 2023 in six international and two Chinese databases. We computed summary statistics with a random-effects model. Publication bias was assessed using funnel plots and heterogeneity using I 2 statistics. Subgroup analysis was performed by age, sex, sample source, and measurement method to explain the heterogeneity.

Results:

17 case-control studies (individuals with ASD, 825; controls, 669) were assessed. Androgen levels were significantly higher in individuals with ASD than that in controls (SMD: 0.27, 95% CI: 0.06-0.48, P=0.01). Subgroup analysis showed significantly elevated levels of urinary total testosterone, urinary DHEA, and free testosterone in individuals with ASD. DHEA level was also significantly elevated in males with ASD. Androgen levels, especially free testosterone, may be elevated in individuals with ASD and DHEA levels may be specifically elevated in males.

 

By coincidence I was just sent the paper below, showing the benefit of Finasteride in one model of autism. 

Therapeutic effect of finasteride through its antiandrogenic and antioxidant role in a propionic acid-induced autism model: Demonstrated by behavioral tests, histological findings and MR spectroscopy

 

I do recall I think it was Tyler, long ago, writing a comment about the potential to use Finasteride in autism.

Some very expensive antiandrogens have been used in autism and this became rather controversial.

We saw in earlier posts that RORα/RORalpha/RORA is a key mechanism where the balance between male and female hormones controls some key autism gene.

 

The schematic illustrates a mechanism through which the observed reduction in RORA in autistic brain may lead to increased testosterone levels through downregulation of aromatase. Through AR, testosterone negatively modulates RORA, whereas estrogen upregulates RORA through ER.

 androgen receptor = AR             estrogen receptor = ER

Cerebellum and neurodevelopmental disorders: RORα is a unifying force

Errors of cerebellar development are increasingly acknowledged as risk factors for neuro-developmental disorders (NDDs), such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), autism spectrum disorder (ASD), and schizophrenia. Evidence has been assembled from cerebellar abnormalities in autistic patients, as well as a range of genetic mutations identified in human patients that affect the cerebellar circuit, particularly Purkinje cells, and are associated with deficits of motor function, learning and social behavior; traits that are commonly associated with autism and schizophrenia. However, NDDs, such as ASD and schizophrenia, also include systemic abnormalities, e.g., chronic inflammation, abnormal circadian rhythms etc., which cannot be explained by lesions that only affect the cerebellum. Here we bring together phenotypic, circuit and structural evidence supporting the contribution of cerebellar dysfunction in NDDs and propose that the transcription factor Retinoid-related Orphan Receptor alpha (RORα) provides the missing link underlying both cerebellar and systemic abnormalities observed in NDDs. We present the role of RORα in cerebellar development and how the abnormalities that occur due to RORα deficiency could explain NDD symptoms. We then focus on how RORα is linked to NDDs, particularly ASD and schizophrenia, and how its diverse extra-cerebral actions can explain the systemic components of these diseases. Finally, we discuss how RORα-deficiency is likely a driving force for NDDs through its induction of cerebellar developmental defects, which in turn affect downstream targets, and its regulation of extracerebral systems, such as inflammation, circadian rhythms, and sexual dimorphism.

  

Figure 2. RORα regulates multiple genes and plays extensive roles in cerebellar development. (A) Key stages of PC development which are regulated by RORα. These are at all stages from embryonic development to adult maintenance. . (B) A schema showing the central role of RORα in multiple cellular processes, that are modified in NDDs. When RORα is reduced (central red circle), its regulation of gene transcription is altered. Here we include the known RORα target genes that are also involved in NDDs. The effects in red illustrate the induced abnormalities according to the direction of change: estrogen and PC development are reduced, circadian rhythms are perturbed, but inflammation and ROS are increased.

 

Sound sensitivity in autism and Nav1.2

At this point today’s post does get complicated.

Researchers have learnt that the sodium ion channel Nav1.2 (expressed by the SCN2A gene) can play a key role in hypersensitivity to sound in autism.

Lack of these ion channels in the cells that produce myelin produces “faulty auditory circuits”, with too much sound sensitivity.

An impairment in myelin structure can trigger cascading effects on neuronal excitability. Sound sensitivity is just one example.

There is a great deal of evidence that genes involved in myelination are miss-expressed in many models of autism. Imaging studies have shown variations in myelination.

 

Scn2a deletion disrupts oligodendroglia function: Implication for myelination, neural circuitry, and auditory hypersensitivity in ASD

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is characterized by a complex etiology, with genetic determinants significantly influencing its manifestation. Among these, the Scn2a gene emerges as a pivotal player, crucially involved in both glial and neuronal functionality. This study elucidates the underexplored roles of Scn2a in oligodendrocytes, and its subsequent impact on myelination and auditory neural processes. The results reveal a nuanced interplay between oligodendrocytes and axons, where Scn2a deletion causes alterations in the intricate process of myelination. This disruption, in turn, instigates changes in axonal properties and neuronal activities at the single cell level. Furthermore, oligodendrocyte-specific Scn2a deletion compromises the integrity of neural circuitry within auditory pathways, leading to auditory hypersensitivity—a common sensory abnormality observed in ASD. Through transcriptional profiling, we identified alterations in the expression of myelin-associated genes, highlighting the cellular consequences engendered by Scn2a deletion. In summary, the findings provide unprecedented insights into the pathway from Scn2a deletion in oligodendrocytes to sensory abnormalities in ASD, underscoring the integral role of Scn2a-mediated myelination in auditory responses. This research thereby provides novel insights into the intricate tapestry of genetic and cellular interactions inherent in ASD.

Therefore, our study underscores the region-specific relationship between myelin integrity and ion channel distribution in the developing brain. We emphasize that any disturbances in myelin structure can trigger cascading effects on neuronal excitability and synaptic function in the CNS, especially at nerve terminals in the auditory nervous system. 

How are Nav1.2  channels, encoded by Scn2a, involved in OL maturation and myelination? One possible explanation is that the activation of Nav1.2 may be pivotal for triggering Cav channel activation, leading to a Ca2+ flux within OLs, which is involved in OL proliferation, migration, and differentiation. Specifically, Ca2+ signaling facilitated by R-type Cav in myelin sheaths at paranodal regions, might influence the growth of myelin sheaths. To activate high-voltage activated calcium channels such as L- and R-Type efficiently, the activation of Nav1.2 channels should be required for depolarizing OL membrane to around -30 mV. Consequently, the synergic interplay between Nav1.2 and Cav channels could amplify calcium signaling in OLs, initiating the differentiation and maturation processes. 

Defects in myelination can create a spectrum of auditory dysfunctions, including hypersensitivity. Our results demonstrated how OL-Scn2a is involved in the relationship between myelin defects, neuronal excitability, and auditory pathology in ASD, potentially paving the way for targeted therapeutic interventions.

 

One subject that some people write to me repeatedly about is self-injurious behavior, so I took note of the paper below.  

Dopamine Transporter Binding Abnormalities Are Associated with Self-injurious Behavior in Autism Spectrum Disorder 

Utilizing single-photon emission computed tomography dopamine transporter scans (DaTscan) we examined whether imaging markers of the dopaminergic system are related to repetitive behaviors as assessed by the Repetitive Behavior Scale-Revised in ASD.

Background: 

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is characterized by impairments in social communication, and restricted repetitive behaviors. Self-injurious behaviors are often observed in individuals with ASD. Dopamine is critical in reward, memory, and motor control. Some propose the nigrostriatal motor pathway may be altered in ASD, and alterations in dopamine are reported in some rodent models based on specific ASD genes. Additionally, repetitive behaviors may to be related to reward systems. Therefore, we examined the dopaminergic system, using DaTscans, to explore its relationship with measures of repetitive behavior in a clinical ASD population.

Design/Methods: 

Twelve participants (aged 18–27) with ASD were recruited from the Thompson Center for Autism and Neurodevelopment and completed the Repetitive Behaviors Scale - Revised (RBS-R). Of the 12 participants, 10 underwent a 45-minute DaTscan. ANOVA was used to compare the dopamine imaging findings with the overall total RB scores on the RBS-R. while other domains of the RBS-R were also investigated in an exploratory manner.

Results: 

Five of the participants had regional deficits in dopamine transporter binding in the striatum on DaTscan. Individuals with deficits on the DaTscan had significantly higher Self-Injurious Endorsed Scores than those with normal scans.

Conclusions: 

Half of the DaTscans obtained were determined abnormal, and abnormal scans were associated with greater endorsing of self-injurious behavior. Larger samples are needed to confirm this, and determine the impact of laterality of abnormalities, but this preliminary work suggests a potential role the dopaminergic system in self-injurious RBs. Elucidation of this relationship may be important for future interventional outcomes, with potential impact on targeted treatment, as the only currently approved medications for ASD are atypical neuroleptics.

 

Dopamine transporter binding abnormalities refer to deviations from the normal levels of dopamine transporter (DAT) in the brain. DAT is a protein on the surface of cells that reabsorbs dopamine from the synapse, regulating its availability.

Imaging techniques like DAT scans (dopamine transporter scans) are used to assess DAT levels. These scans measure the binding of radiotracers to DAT, with lower binding indicating reduced DAT levels.

Dopamine transporter binding abnormalities have been linked to various neurological and psychiatric conditions, including:

•                 Parkinson's disease: Degeneration of dopamine-producing neurons in the substantia nigra, a hallmark of Parkinson's disease, leads to a significant decrease in dopamine levels and DAT binding in the striatum.

•                 Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): Some studies suggest that individuals with ADHD may have abnormal DAT function, though the nature of the abnormality (increased or decreased DAT) is debated.

•                 Autism spectrum disorder (ASD): Research suggests that a subgroup of individuals with ASD may have DAT abnormalities, potentially linked to repetitive behaviors and social difficulties.

•                 Addiction: Dopamine plays a central role in reward and motivation. Drugs like cocaine and methamphetamine can cause long-term changes in DAT function, potentially contributing to addiction.

DAT binding abnormalities may not always translate to functional impairments.

 

Treatment options for DAT binding abnormalities

Unfortunately, medications that directly target Dopamine Transporter (DAT) binding abnormalities do not exist.

In Parkinson's disease the goal is to increase dopamine levels in the brain. Medications like levodopa, a dopamine precursor, or dopamine agonists (drugs that mimic dopamine) are used.

  

Conclusion

It certainly is not easy to figure out how to treat autism and its troubling symptoms like self-injury. Our reader currently trying to make sure his second child does not have severe autism is wise to invest his time now.

Today we added agmatine and choline to our list of preventative strategies to consider.

As regards strategies to treat autism in children and adults, we see that the research very often is repeating what has already been published over the past two decades.

Ion channels do seem to be central to understanding and treating autism.