Diamox or Meldonium would make it easier
Several times recently the subject of pH (acidity/alkalinity) has come up in my discussions with fellow parents. It is not a subject that gets attention in the autism research, so here is my contribution to the subject.
If your child has a blood gas test a day after a seizure
and it shows high pH, this is not the result of the seizure, but a likely cause
of it. Treat the elevated pH to avoid another seizure and likely also improve
autism symptoms. It may be respiratory alkalosis which is caused by
hyperventilation, due to stress, anxiety etc.
The regulation of pH inside and outside brain cells is a
delicate balance with far-reaching consequences. Subtle shifts toward acidity
(low pH) or alkalinity (high pH) can alter calcium handling, neuronal
excitability, and ultimately drive seizures, fatigue, or even inflammation.
This interplay becomes especially important in conditions like autism,
epilepsy, and mitochondrial disease, where metabolism and excitability are
already dysregulated.
You can
measure blood pH quite easily, but within cells different parts are maintained
at very different levels of pH and this you will not be able to measure. Blood
pH is about 7.4 (slightly alkaline) the gogli apparatus is slightly acidic,
whereas the lysome is very acidic (pH about 4.7).
pH and Calcium Balance
Calcium (Ca²⁺) is central to neuronal excitability. Small
pH changes shift the balance between intracellular and extracellular calcium:
- Alkalosis
(↑ pH): reduces extracellular calcium
availability, destabilizes neuronal membranes, and promotes
hyperexcitability and seizures.
- Acidosis
(↓ pH): activates acid-sensing ion channels
(ASICs), leading to Na⁺ and Ca²⁺ influx and further excitability.
Thus, both too much acidity and too much alkalinity can
increase seizure risk, though through different mechanisms.
Your body should tightly regulate its pH. You can only
nudge it slightly up or down. Even small changes can be worthwhile in some
cases.
When extracellular (ionized) calcium enters neurons through
ion channels it can drive inflammation, excitability, and mitochondrial stress.
Calcium needs to be in the right place and in autism it often is not, for a
wide variety of reasons.
Mitochondrial Disease and pH
Mitochondria produce ATP through oxidative
phosphorylation. Dysfunction can impair this process and lead to accumulation
of lactate (acidosis) or, paradoxically, reduced proton flux (relative
alkalosis). In autism, mitochondrial dysfunction is reported in a significant
minority (10–20%) of cases.
Hyperventilation and Alkalosis
Another often-overlooked contributor is hyperventilation.
By blowing off CO₂, blood pH rises (respiratory alkalosis), leading to reduced
ionized calcium and increased excitability. This is the reason why
hyperventilation is used during EEG testing to provoke seizures in susceptible
individuals.
Therapeutic Approaches - Adjusting pH
Several therapies—old and new—intentionally alter pH
balance:
1. Sodium and Potassium Bicarbonate
- Mechanism:
Buffers acids, increases systemic pH (alkalinization).
- Applications:
Beneficial in some cases of autism and epilepsy, as reported in blogs and
small studies.
- Note:
Raises extracellular pH, which can reduce ASIC activation but may increase
excitability if alkalosis is excessive.
- Beyond
buffering, sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) has been shown to trigger
anti-inflammatory vagal nerve pathways. This effect may be especially
valuable in neuroinflammation seen in autism and epilepsy.
2. Acetazolamide (Diamox)
- Mechanism:
A carbonic anhydrase inhibitor that causes bicarbonate loss in the urine,
lowering blood pH (mild acidosis).
- Neurological
Effects: Used as an anti-seizure drug,
especially in patients with channelopathies and mitochondrial disorders.
- In
Climbers: At altitude, the body tends toward
alkalosis due to hyperventilation (blowing off CO₂). Diamox counteracts
this by inducing a mild metabolic acidosis, which stimulates ventilation,
improves oxygenation, and prevents acute mountain sickness (AMS). This is
why mountaineers often describe Diamox as helping them “breathe at night”
in the mountains.
3. Zonisamide
- Mechanism:
Another carbonic anhydrase inhibitor, with both anti-seizure and mild
acidifying effects.
- Benefit:
Often used in refractory epilepsy.
ASICs: Acid-Sensing Ion Channels
ASICs are neuronal ion channels directly gated by protons
(H⁺). Their activity is pH-sensitive:
- Low
pH (acidosis): Activates ASICs → Na⁺/Ca²⁺ influx →
excitability and seizures.
- High
pH (alkalosis): Reduces ASIC activity, but destabilizes
calcium balance in other ways.
ASIC Mutations
Mutations in ASIC genes can alter how neurons respond to
pH shifts. In theory, modest therapeutic modulation of pH (via bicarbonate or
acetazolamide) could normalize excitability in patients with ASIC mutations.
| ||||
Give that mouse Diamox!
Meldonium vs Diamox — Two Paths to Survive
Altitude
During the Soviet–Afghan war in the 1980s, Russian troops
were supplied with meldonium, while American soldiers and climbers commonly
used acetazolamide (Diamox) for altitude adaptation. The Mujahideen and Taliban
need neither, because they have already adapted to the low oxygen level.
Meldonium is a Latvian drug made famous by the tennis
star Maria Sharapova who was found to be taking it for many years. It is a very
plausible therapy to boost the performance of your mitochondria and so might
help some autism. I know some people have tried it.
Although both drugs were used to improve performance
under hypoxia, they worked in almost opposite ways:
At high altitude without Diamox
- You
hyperventilate to compensate for low oxygen.
- Hyperventilation
↓ CO₂ in the blood → respiratory alkalosis (↑ pH).
- The
alkalosis suppresses breathing (since the brainstem senses “too alkaline,
slow down”), which is why people breathe shallowly at night, leading to
periodic apnea and low oxygen saturation.
With Diamox
- Diamox
blocks carbonic anhydrase in the kidneys → you excrete more bicarbonate
(HCO₃⁻).
- This
causes a metabolic acidosis (↓ pH).
- The
brainstem now senses blood as “acidic,” which stimulates breathing.
- So,
you hyperventilate more, but this time it’s sustained, because the
metabolic acidosis counterbalances the respiratory alkalosis.
The net effect
- Without
Diamox: hyperventilation → alkalosis → suppressed breathing → poor
oxygenation.
- With
Diamox: hyperventilation + mild metabolic acidosis → balanced pH →
sustained ventilation and better oxygen delivery.
The Irony
- Meldonium
- indirect alkalinization to reduce stress on cells.
- Diamox
- deliberate acidification to stimulate respiration.
- Both
approaches improved function under low oxygen, but they pulled physiology
in opposite pH directions.
Another irony is that not only is Meldonium banned in
sport, but so is Diamox. Diamox is banned because it is a diuretic and so can
be used to mask the use of other drugs.
Now an example showing the impact of when pH control
within the cell is dysfunctional.
GPR89A - the Golgi “Post Office” gene that keeps
our cells running
When we think about genes involved in neurodevelopment,
most people imagine genes that directly control brain signaling or neuron
growth. But some genes quietly do their work behind the scenes, keeping our
cellular “factories” running smoothly. One such gene is GPR89A, a gene that
plays a critical role in regulating Golgi pH — and when it malfunctions, the
consequences can ripple all the way to autism and intellectual disability (ID).
The Golgi Apparatus: The Cell’s Post Office
To understand GPR89A, it helps to picture the cell as a
factory:
- The
endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is the protein factory, producing raw products
— proteins and lipids.
- The
Golgi apparatus is the post office, modifying, sorting, and shipping these
products to their proper destinations.
Just like a real post office, the Golgi must maintain
precise conditions to function. One key condition is pH, the acidity inside the
Golgi.
GPR89A: The Golgi’s pH Regulator
Inside the Golgi, acidity is carefully balanced by:
- V-ATPase
pumps, which push protons (H⁺) in to acidify the lumen.
- Anion
channels like GPR89A, which allow negative ions (Cl⁻, HCO₃⁻) to flow in,
neutralizing the electrical charge and keeping the pH just right.
Think of GPR89A as the electrical wiring in the post
office: without it, the machinery may be overloaded or misfiring, even if the
raw materials (proteins) are fine.
When Golgi pH Goes Wrong
If GPR89A is mutated:
1.
The Golgi cannot maintain its normal acidic
environment.
2.
Enzymes inside the Golgi — responsible for
adding sugar chains to proteins (glycosylation) — cannot work properly.
3.
Proteins may become misfolded, unstable, or
misrouted. Some may be sent to the wrong destination, while others are
degraded.
This is akin to a post office with wrong sorting labels:
packages (proteins) either go to the wrong address or get lost entirely.
Consequences for the Brain
Proteins are not just passive molecules; many are
receptors, ion channels, adhesion molecules, or signaling factors essential for
brain development. Mis-glycosylated proteins can lead to:
- Disrupted
cell signaling
- Impaired
synapse formation
- Altered
neuronal communication
The end result can manifest as intellectual disability,
autism spectrum disorders, or other neurodevelopmental conditions, because
neurons are particularly sensitive to these trafficking and signaling errors.
Could Modulating Blood pH Help?
Since Golgi pH depends partly on cellular bicarbonate and
proton balance, I have speculated whether small changes in blood pH could
indirectly influence Golgi function:
- Sodium/potassium
bicarbonate
- Increases
extracellular bicarbonate and buffering capacity.
- Might
slightly influence intracellular pH and indirectly affect Golgi pH.
- Acetazolamide
(Diamox):
- Inhibits
carbonic anhydrase, altering H⁺ and bicarbonate handling in cells.
- Could
theoretically shift intracellular pH including Golgi pH
Systemic pH changes are
heavily buffered by cells, so the impact on Golgi pH is likely to be modest at
best.
Neither approach has been validated
in human studies for improving glycosylation. Currently, there is no
established therapy for GPR89A mutations.
Because there is no treatment, a reasonable option is a
brief, carefully monitored trial.
- Try
both interventions (bicarbonate then Diamox) for a short period.
- Observe
for any measurable benefit in function or clinical outcomes.
- If
there is no benefit, stop the trial — nothing is lost.
This approach allows cautious exploration without
committing to a long-term therapy that may be ineffective.
The Bigger Picture
Even though GPR89A itself is not classified as a major
autism or ID gene, its role in Golgi ion balance and glycosylation highlights
how basic cellular “infrastructure” genes can profoundly affect brain
development.
GPR89A reminds us that neurodevelopment is not only about
neurons or synapses but also about the tiny cellular logistics systems that
make them function. Maintaining Golgi pH is not glamorous, but without it, the
entire cellular supply chain collapses, illustrating a pathway from a single
gene mutation → cellular dysfunction → potential autism and ID outcomes.
Manipulating blood pH with bicarbonate or Diamox is an
intriguing idea, will it provide a benefit?
Conclusion
pH regulation is a critical but underappreciated factor
in autism, epilepsy, and mitochondrial disease. Subtle shifts in acidity or
alkalinity affect calcium handling, ASIC activation, and neuronal excitability.
Therapeutic strategies—from bicarbonates to carbonic anhydrase inhibitors—show
that intentionally modulating pH can be both protective and symptomatic.
Understanding the individual’s underlying metabolic and genetic context (eg
mitochondrial function, ASIC mutations etc) will help determine whether a person
might benefit more from raising or lowering pH.
For people with inflammatory conditions like some autism,
or even MS, the simple idea of using baking soda to activate the vagus nerve is
interesting.
· Sodium bicarbonate → slight systemic alkalization.
· Alkalization → reduced acidosis-related inflammatory signals.
· Sensory neurons detect the pH change → activate vagus nerve.
· Vagus nerve triggers cholinergic anti-inflammatory pathway → lowers pro-inflammatory cytokines.
We saw this in an old post and the researchers even went
as far as severing the vagus nerve to prove it.
Potassium bicarbonate is a better long-term choice than
sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) since most people lack potassium and have too
much sodium already. It is cheap and OTC.
Diamox, Meldonium and Zonisamide are all used long term.
If you mention any of this to your doctor, expect a blank
look coming back! Unless he/she is a mountaineer or perhaps a Latvian sports
doctor!